Why Your Cookies Are Cakey And How To Fix Them

Last Updated on November 8, 2022

You love baking cakes and cookies, but they always turn out dry or crumbly. What gives?

Cake batter usually contains eggs, flour, sugar, butter, milk, vanilla extract, and other ingredients. The problem is that these ingredients don’t mix well together. They tend to separate into layers, leaving behind a dense cake base and air pockets. This makes baked goods heavy and less moist.

To solve this problem, add some leavening agents such as baking soda or baking powder. These chemical compounds react with water to produce carbon dioxide gas bubbles. When the bubbles expand during cooking, they push the batter around, creating lightness and volume.

Why Your Cookies Are Cakey?

When making cookies, there are several things that could cause your cookies to become overly moist and/or cake-like. These include:

1) Using Too Much Dough – When mixing the dry ingredients together, add only enough water to form a smooth ball of dough. Do not knead the mixture as you would for bread; just combine everything well. Once combined, roll the dough into balls about 1 inch thick. Place each ball onto a greased cookie sheet and flatten slightly.

2) Over mixing – Mix all the ingredients together before adding any liquid. Be careful not to overwork the batter.

3) Not Removing Baking Powder From Cookie Sheet Before Adding Sugar – After placing the rolled-out dough on the cookie sheets, sprinkle some granulated sugar evenly across the surface of the dough. Then gently press down lightly with your fingers to remove air bubbles.

4) Excessive Cooking Time – Bake the cookies for longer than necessary. Make sure to watch carefully after 10 minutes. Remove the pan from the oven once the edges begin to brown. Let cool completely before removing from the pans.

5) Omitting Eggs – Some recipes call for egg yolks instead of whole eggs. Egg whites contain less fat than whole eggs, so they won’t weigh down the finished product. However, egg yolk contains more protein than white, so it helps give structure to the final product.

Cakey cookies are caused by an imbalance in the fat:sugar: flour ratio. Over-flouring cookies result in drier, cakier results. When you don’t measure flour correctly, you’ll end up with too much.

To get the best results, weigh your ingredients rather than using volume. Another factor that leads to cakey cookies is improper cooling time. After baking, allow the cookies to cool completely before removing them from the pan. Otherwise, the hot oil or butter inside the cookies will melt causing them to fall apart.

How Can I Prevent My Cookies From Being Too Soft Or Caking?

To ensure that your cookies stay crispy and chewy, follow these tips:

1) Make sure that all of your ingredients are at room temperature. Cold ingredients like ice cream and frozen foods will affect how well your cookies cook.

2) Use a stand mixer rather than hand mixing your dough. Using a stand mixer allows you to knead the dough without having to worry about breaking apart the mixture. A stand mixer makes it easier to incorporate air into the dough.

3) Bake your cookies at 375 degrees Fahrenheit or lower. Baking at high temperatures will allow the cookies to brown faster. Since most baked goods contain butter, sugar, eggs, and other fats, they require heat to melt the fats and create steam inside the oven. At high temperatures, the fats begin to break down quickly and start burning. Lowering the temperature slows down the process and prevents the fats from melting completely.

4) Do not roll out your dough too thin. Rolling out the dough thinly means that the surface area exposed to the heat is smaller. Therefore, the cookies will take longer to fully cook. Instead, use medium thicknesses of rolled-out dough.

5) Always preheat your oven first. Preheating the oven ensures that the oven reaches its ideal temperature as soon as the food goes in. In addition, preheated ovens release fewer harmful gases which help eliminate odors and smoke during cooking.

Why Your Cookies Have A Cakey Texture?

Here are some of the reasons why your cookies tend to have a cakey texture.

The Sugar And Butter Was Overbeaten

Overbeating causes the sugars and fats to become incorporated into each other. This creates a smooth paste that’s difficult to separate when rolling out the cookie dough. The overmixing also incorporates air bubbles into the batter.

These tiny pockets of gas expand while baking creating large holes throughout the cookie. As a result, the center becomes soft and spongy. If you beat the dough for very long then the gluten strands within the dough can develop enough strength to hold onto the air bubbles. These strong gluten strands trap the air bubbles between themselves making the cookies tough.

You Used Volume Measurements

When measuring flour, always use weight measurements instead of volume measures. Flour weighs more per cup than liquid does so if you’re weighing your dry ingredients, make sure to add extra cups of flour until you reach the desired consistency.

Also, be careful when adding liquids because 1/8th teaspoon of salt may seem insignificant but it adds up over several batches. When you are measuring in volume measure, try using a scale with grams. It’s much better to weigh your ingredients accurately since this method helps prevent errors caused by inaccurate measurement.

Too Much Egg

Egg yolks should never exceed 60% of the total egg amount used in any recipe. Too many egg whites cause the proteins in the egg white to coagulate causing them to clump together. This results in an unappetizingly dense cookie.

If you want to increase the protein content in your cookies, simply replace one whole egg with two egg whites. You’ll still get plenty of flavor and moisture from the egg whites. If you don’t like the taste of raw egg, consider replacing it with 2 teaspoons of vinegar. Vinegar contains acetic acid which breaks down the proteins found in the egg whites. However, do note that the vinegar must be added after beating the egg whites otherwise the mixture won’t form properly.

How To Not Get Cakey Cookies?

There are ways to avoid getting cakey cookies. Here are some tips:

1) Use only room temperature butter or margarine. Cold butter makes the fat globules stick together resulting in a denser cookie. Also, cold butter tends to create a harder crust on top of the baked cookie.

2) Be patient! Baking takes time. Don’t expect instant gratification. Wait at least 10 minutes before taking a bite.

3) Make sure all of your ingredients are measured correctly. For example, if you mix too little sugar into the dough, the finished product will not spread easily. On the contrary, if you put way too much sugar in the dough, the final product will be extremely sweet.

4) Try mixing fewer eggs into the dough. One whole egg is usually sufficient to produce a tender cookie.

5) Add just enough water to moisten the dough without leaving it soggy.

Beat The Butter And Sugar By Hand

The best way to incorporate air into the batter is through vigorous hand-mixing.

Using a mixer defeats the purpose of incorporating air into the dough as well as creates a lot of unnecessary stress on the dough. Instead, gently fold the softened butter and sugars together with a spatula. Mix slowly and carefully. Do not overwork the dough.

If you want perfect cookies the beating the butter by hand is essential. Using a stand mixer can result in tough cookies due to excessive heat generated during the process.

The Soft Chocolate Chip Cookies Of Your Dreams | Bigger Bolder Baking

Melt The Butter Instead Of Beating It

Instead of beating the butter, melt it first then stir in the other ingredients. Doing this prevents the fats from separating out of the milk solids.

This also allows for easier incorporation of the wet ingredients into the dry ones.

Always Use Weight Instead Of Volume

When baking, use weight instead of volume measurements. A cup of flour weighs 4 ounces while a tablespoon measures about 3.5 ounces. Therefore, if you’re following recipes written in cups, multiply their weights by four.

Do you ever find yourself eating something delicious but then feeling guilty afterwards because you think you shouldn’t have eaten it?
Well, cookies are no different!
There’s nothing wrong with having a cookie every now and then, but if you eat too much of them, you might end up gaining weight instead of losing it.
I’m going to explain you how to fix your cookies so they don’t become cakey and leave you feeling bad after eating them.

Why Your Cookies Have A Cakey Texture

Cakey cookies are caused by the baking powder used in the recipe. Baking powder contains sodium bicarbonate, which reacts with moisture in the dough to produce carbon dioxide gas. This gas expands during baking, causing the cookie to puff up. As the cookies cool down, the CO2 gas escapes from the baked product, leaving behind a soft texture. How To Prevent Cakes From Being Cakey If you bake cookies using baking soda instead of baking powder, the cookies won’t get cakey because baking soda doesn’t react with moisture to form carbon dioxide gas. Instead, baking soda reacts with acids to form carbonates, which give the baked good a crunchy texture.

The Sugar And Butter Was Overbeaten

Overbeating sugar and butter together creates air pockets within the mixture. These air pockets expand as the cookies bake, making them larger than intended. Overbeating also produces a tough cookie.

You Used Volume Measurements

If you used volume measurements instead of weight measurements, you could end up with dry cookies because you didn’t get enough moisture into the dough. You Used Too Much Flour

Too Much Egg

You Used Too Little Water

You Used Baking Powder Instead Of Baking Soda

If you used baking powder instead of baking soda, you could try using 1/2 cup of baking soda and 1/4 cup of cream of tartar. This will help raise the pH level of the batter.


You can use baking soda but if you use baking powder, you will get better results. Baking powder contains sodium bicarbonate baking soda and cream of tartar. Cream of tartar is a white crystalline substance that is produced from grapes. It is added to baking powders because it helps stabilize the chemical reaction between the other ingredients.


To make a good spread, you need to combine butter with flour and salt. Then beat in milk until smooth. Add cheese and stir well. Spread onto bread slices and bake at 350 degrees F 180 degrees C for 10 minutes or until golden brown.


To make a good powder, you need to combine flour with salt and pepper. Then mix in butter and milk until smooth. Add eggs and stir well. Pour into a greased pan and bake at 350 degrees Fahrenheit 180 degrees Celsius for 30 minutes or until set.


Puff pastry is a type of dough used to make pastries such as croissants, puff pastries, Danish pastries, and turnovers. It is usually made from shortening or lard, sugar, flour, yeast, and salt. The ingredients are mixed together and allowed to rest overnight. Once rested, the mixture is rolled out into sheets and cut into desired shapes. After cutting, the pieces are placed onto baking sheets lined with parchment paper and baked at 375 degrees F 190 C for about 15 minutes.

How To Not Get Cakey Cookies

Cakey cookies are not always bad but if you want to avoid getting cakey cookies try using a different recipe. For instance, instead of making chocolate chip cookie dough, try making vanilla wafer cookie dough. This way you won’t get any of the chocolate chips in your cookies.

Beat The Butter And Sugar By Hand

If you’re baking something sweet, such as a pie, cake, or cupcakes, you’ll probably want to beat butter and sugar together until light and fluffy. It’s important to beat these ingredients together slowly and gently, otherwise you could end up with a lumpy batter. Use A Stand Mixer Or Electric Beater Answer: If you’re baking something sweet like a pie, cake, cupcake, or muffins, you’ll probably want a stand mixer or electric beater to mix the ingredients together. These tools are great because they allow you to beat the ingredients together quickly and easily.

Melt The Butter Instead Of Beating It

You can melt the butter instead of beating it if you’d prefer. To do this, place the butter in a bowl set over a pan of simmering water. Make sure the bottom of the bowl doesn’t touch the water. Stir the butter occasionally until it melts completely. Remove from the heat and let cool slightly. Beat With A Spoon Answer: If you don’t own a stand mixer or electric beaters, you can still beat the butter and sugar together using a spoon. Place the butter and sugar in a medium-sized bowl. Use a wooden spoon to stir the mixture together until it becomes light and fluffy.

Always Use Weight Instead Of Volume

To measure the volume of ingredients, use a measuring cup. For example, 1 cup of flour weighs 140 grams. To measure the weight of a liquid, use a scale. For example, 1 liter of milk weighs about 150 grams. Always weigh liquids rather than measuring them by volume. Use A Digital Scale

Make Sure You’re Using The Correct Leavening Agent

Always use the correct leavening agent. Baking powder contains baking soda and cream of tartar. Baking soda contains sodium bicarbonate and cream of tartar contains potassium bitartrate. Both of these substances react together to produce carbon dioxide gas. This gas helps to raise the dough during the rising process. It is important to know how much of each ingredient to use because if you use too much of either substance, the dough won’t rise properly.

Tips For Next Time

If you are planning to bake bread, always remember to preheat the oven to 400 degrees Fahrenheit. Bread needs to be baked at a certain temperature to ensure proper rising and texture.

Bake A Test Cookie First

To test if your oven is working properly, try baking a cookie. It’s easy to tell whether your oven is working correctly if the cookie turns out perfectly golden brown. If not, check the thermostat and adjust it accordingly. Use A Thermometer To Check Temperature

Always Read The Ingredients And Recipe Carefully

Cooking is a science and an art. Cooking is about making sure that every ingredient is used to its full potential. This includes using the right ingredients, measuring everything correctly, and following the recipe carefully.

How does baking soda affect cookies?

If you put less baking soda into cookie dough, you’ll get a denser cookie. This is because the reaction between the acid sour and baking soda baking powder creates carbon dioxide gas. The more baking soda you use, the lighter the cookie will be.

What happens if you don’t put baking soda in cookies?

Baking soda doesn’t make cookies cakey. It’s actually used to help cookies stay soft and chewy. Baking soda reacts with acids in the recipe to form carbon dioxide gas. Carbon dioxide gas helps to give baked goods lift and volume.

What happens if you put less baking soda in cookies?

If you bake cookies without adding baking soda, they won’t turn out right. This is because baking soda helps to leaven lighten the dough. Without baking soda, the dough won’t rise properly. As a result, the cookies will end up dense and heavy. To fix this problem, simply add 1/4 cup of baking soda to every 2 cups of flour.

Why are my cookies too fluffy?

Baking soda helps to leaven the dough and gives the cookies a light texture. It’s important to note that baking soda reacts differently depending on how hot your oven is. For instance, if your oven is very hot, baking soda won’t react properly. Instead, you’ll need to use baking powder instead. Baking powder works similarly to baking soda but it doesn’t need to be mixed with liquid.

How do you make cookies not cakey?

To get the perfect cookie, you need to bake them correctly. Cookies should be cooked until golden brown. To test if your cookies are done, take a toothpick and poke into the center of the cookie. If the toothpick comes out clean, your cookies are ready. If your cookies are still soft after cooling, try adding a teaspoon of sugar to each cookie. This will help to harden the cookie.

Does baking soda make cookies rise or spread?

Baking soda does not make cookies rise or spread. It only helps the cookies to taste better. Baking soda is used to give baked goods a lighter flavor. Baking powder is another ingredient that gives baked goods a lighter flavor but it also makes the baked good rise. How long do I let my cookies cool?

Does baking soda make cookies cakey?

Cakey cookies are usually caused by using too much flour. You can try adding baking soda instead of salt to help lighten the texture. Also, if you bake the cookie dough longer, it will become more tender.

In summary, if your cookies are cakey, it could be because you are using too much flour, or too much egg, or not enough butter or sugar. The only way to know for sure is to test, test, test. And even when you find out exactly what works, remember that when it comes to cooking, no result is written in stone.

Latest posts by Daisy (see all)

Leave a Comment